SciFi Futures
← Concepts
AI & Robotics

Self-replicating von Neumann probe

An autonomous interstellar probe that mines a destination system, builds copies of itself and sends them onward, exploring the galaxy exponentially.

In shortSelf-replicating von Neumann probe, from We Are Legion (We Are Bob) (Dennis E. Taylor, 2016), is at technology readiness level 1 of 9 (basic principles observed) at its weakest link. Held back by Reactionless (propellantless, non-photon) thrust. Science status: contradicts well-established physics as currently understood. Estimated new funding to unlock: $163B–925B (a floor; some parts are priced only to early research).

Bob Johansson's uploaded mind runs a probe with a reactionless SURGE drive; at each system he mines asteroids, prints new probes with autofactories and copies himself into them.
We Are Legion (We Are Bob) by Dennis E. Taylor, 2016Set in 2133Physics says noDepends on something known physics rules out

Closest todayNASA's 1980 self-replicating factory study; RepRap partial self-copying; Starshot-class probes.

Dependency stack

Research TRL 1–3Development TRL 4–6Deployment TRL 7–9
Sort by
  • Mining, refining and building a complete new probe from local material
    ✕3 blockers›
    • Closure ratio — semiconductors, bearings and precision parts cannot be made from regolith with known processes
    • Error accumulation across generations without human quality control
    • Full-autonomy fault recovery over years
    TRL 2
  • The probe is controlled by an emulated human mind, as depicted
    ✕3 blockers›
    • Unknown sufficient level of detail; no accepted criterion for when an emulation is the same person
    • Static connectomes lack synaptic weights, neuromodulatory state and glial contributions
    • Validation problem; without the original brain's activity you cannot check the copy
    plausibleTRL 2
    • Wiring without weights and molecular state does not specify a mind
      ✕3 blockers›
      • Unknown which molecular species are sufficient to infer functional synaptic weight
      • Antibody or barcode multiplexing depth, and uniform labeling across centimetre-scale tissue
      • Fixation chemistry that preserves both ultrastructure and labile post-translational state
      plausibleTRL 2
      • Theory decides which molecular variables must be measured at all
        ✕1 blocker›
        • Unknown sufficient level of biological detail
        plausibleTRL 2
        • Wiring diagrams constrain and test circuit models
          ✕3 blockers›
          • Human proofreading of AI segmentation dominates cost; 2025 methods imply tens of billions of dollars for one mouse brain
          • Imaging throughput and storage; a human brain at EM resolution is of order 100+ exabytes of raw data
          • Sectioning or expanding whole large brains without tissue loss or distortion
          TRL 3
          • Ultrastructure must survive preservation before it can be imaged
            ✕3 blockers›
            • Ischemic damage starts within minutes of circulatory arrest, before perfusion can begin
            • Aldehyde fixation may destroy molecular state (phosphorylation, receptor conformation) that could carry memory
            • No assay proves preserved tissue still contains the information an emulation would need
            TRL 4
          • Automated segmentation and tracing of exabyte-scale image volumes
            TRL 8
      • Molecular readout is only useful registered to every traced synapse
        TRL 3
    • Determines which biological detail must be simulated for cognition to appear
      plausibleTRL 2
    • Activity from the source brain is the only way to validate the emulation
      ✕3 blockers›
      • Optical methods cannot penetrate a human skull or image below ~1 mm of tissue
      • Channel count, heat dissipation and uplink bandwidth for ~86 billion neurons
      • Displaced tissue volume and vascular damage scale with the number of inserted probes
      plausibleTRL 2
      • Whole-brain coverage needs sensors orders of magnitude smaller than current shanks
        ✕3 blockers›
        • No scheme to individually power and address millions of untethered sub-cellular devices
        • Egress bandwidth; nanoparticles can stimulate but cannot yet report spikes off-board
        • Clearance, aggregation and long-term toxicity of persistent intraparenchymal devices
        plausibleTRL 3
        • Non-surgical delivery requires crossing from blood into brain parenchyma
          ✕3 blockers›
          • Receptor targeting is species-specific; capsids binding human TfR1 often fail in macaque
          • Pre-existing anti-AAV immunity excludes a large fraction of patients and blocks redosing
          • Dose needed for brain-wide coverage drives liver toxicity and manufacturing cost
          TRL 4
          • Designed capsid and shuttle proteins are the main route to receptor-specific transcytosis
            ✕1 blocker›
            • Designing catalysis and conformational dynamics
            TRL 6
        • Devices resident in tissue for decades must not provoke encapsulation
          ✕3 blockers›
          • Micromotion between rigid device and pulsating tissue drives chronic inflammation
          • Thin-film encapsulation (polyimide, parylene, SiC) eventually admits water and fails
          • Electrode charge-injection limits and corrosion under years of continuous stimulation
          TRL 4
      • Recording must remain stable for the duration of a life, not months
        TRL 4
      • Electrode arrays are today's only route to single-neuron recording in humans
        ✕2 blockers›
        • Tissue response degrades signal over years
        • Channel count and wireless bandwidth
        TRL 6
        • Channel count is limited by wireless data and power budget
          ✕3 blockers›
          • Tissue heating caps implant power at a few hundred milliwatts, which bounds radio and compute
          • Raw broadband neural data exceeds the link, forcing on-implant spike detection and compression
          • Battery or wireless-power lifetime versus the decades a permanent interface implies
          TRL 5
          • Implant power density sets what telemetry and on-board compute are affordable
            ✕2 blockers›
            • Cycle life of lithium-metal anodes
            • Thermal runaway safety
            TRL 6
    • An individual's wiring diagram is the irreducible input
      TRL 3
    • Running the model at biological speed requires brain-scale compute
      ✕3 blockers›
      • Synaptic state alone needs petabytes of high-bandwidth memory, which dominates cost
      • All-to-all spike traffic makes the problem interconnect-bound, not FLOP-bound
      • Energy per synaptic event is ~1e6 times worse than biology, so a real-time human emulation implies large power draw
      TRL 4
  • The SURGE drive as depicted needs no propellant, which violates momentum conservation
    • Conservation of momentum
    • Claimed signals repeatedly traced to measurement artifacts
    forbiddenTRL 1
  • Raw materials for replication come from asteroids at each system
    ✕3 blockers›
    • Anchoring and excavating in milligravity on rubble-pile bodies with unknown cohesion
    • Remote assay of metal grade before committing a mining mission
    • Low-energy return trajectories and transit times of years
    TRL 3
  • Power for mining and factories far from any star's useful sunlight
    TRL 5
  • Realistic substitute for the SURGE drive, refueled from local volatiles
    ✕3 blockers›
    • No fusion device with gain small and light enough to fly
    • Specific power (kW/kg) including radiators orders of magnitude short of torch-ship needs
    • Thrust augmentation and nozzle detachment at MW–GW power
    plausibleTRL 2
  • Interstellar cruising at a few percent of c
    ✕3 blockers›
    • No facility accelerates dust grains to 0.1 c for impact testing
    • Shield mass grows with speed squared and trip length
    • Gas impacts at >0.5 c produce intense secondary radiation inside the ship
    plausibleTRL 2

Who could unlock it

Reactionless (propellantless, non-photon) thrustTRL 1bottleneck
  • Martin TajmarResearcher, TU Dresden
    Led the 2021 high-precision EmDrive and Mach-effect thruster tests that traced earlier claimed thrust to thermal and electrical artefacts.
  • Harold 'Sonny' WhiteResearcher, Limitless Space Institute
    Led NASA Eagleworks, whose 2016 J. Propulsion and Power paper reported EmDrive thrust that later work did not reproduce.
  • IVO LtdStartup
    Flew its 'Quantum Drive' on the BARRY-1 cubesat (Transporter-9, November 2023), but the satellite failed in early 2024 before the drive was turned on.
  • DARPAProgram
    Gave the University of Plymouth's Mike McCulloch a ~$1.3M grant (2018) to test 'quantised inertia' propulsion ideas; no confirmed thrust resulted.
Autonomous self-replicating industryTRL 2
  • Alex ElleryResearcher, Carleton University
    Studies self-replicating lunar machines built from regolith-derived materials, with 3D printing and electronics as the closure bottleneck
  • Adrian BowyerResearcher, University of Bath (emeritus)
    Founded RepRap, the open-source 3D printer that printed about half its own parts (2008-2011)
  • Gregory ChirikjianResearcher, Johns Hopkins / National University of Singapore
    NASA NIAC study on self-replicating lunar factory architectures, with physical self-replicating robot prototypes
  • NASA Institute for Advanced ConceptsProgram
    Funded the 2004 self-replicating lunar factory and kinematic cellular automata studies; builds on the 1980 NASA self-replicating lunar factory study
Whole-brain emulationTRL 2
  • Eon SystemsStartup
    Ran a FlyWire-based whole fly brain emulation driving a MuJoCo body through multiple behaviors (2026); targeting a mouse emulation
  • Philip ShiuResearcher, Eon Systems
    Author of the whole Drosophila brain computational model (Nature 2024) and co-author of the State of Brain Emulation Report 2025
  • Carboncopies FoundationProgram
    Non-profit coordinating WBE research, a Brain Emulation Challenge and an emulation ethics framework (2025)
  • HHMI Janelia FlyEMAcademic lab
    Published the complete Drosophila central nervous system connectome (2025-2026), the data emulations depend on
Asteroid resource extractionTRL 3
  • AstroForgeStartup
    Odin was lost in deep space after launch in Feb 2025; the 200 kg DeepSpace-2 was completed in 2026 to attempt an asteroid rendezvous
  • Karman+Startup
    Announced in Jul 2026 that its first mission targets asteroid Apophis; open-sourced its Prospector mission-design tool in Sep 2026
  • TransAstraStartup
    Running an investor- and customer-funded 2026 study on bagging a 100 t asteroid and moving it to a stable orbit for processing
  • Dante LaurettaResearcher, University of Arizona
    Principal investigator of OSIRIS-REx, which returned 121.6 g of Bennu sample in 2023
Space fission power systemsTRL 5
  • NASA Fission Surface PowerProgram
    NASA/DOE project that in August 2025 issued a draft call for a >=100 kWe, <15 t lunar reactor to launch by about 2030.
  • Los Alamos National LaboratoryGovernment lab
    With NASA Glenn, ran KRUSTY, a 5 kWt Kilopower reactor test for 28 hours at the Nevada National Security Site (2018).
  • Patrick McClureResearcher, Los Alamos National Laboratory
    Led the KRUSTY/Kilopower reactor design and test effort.
  • Lockheed MartinCompany
    Won a 2022 NASA/INL Fission Surface Power design contract (with BWXT and Creare) and proposes a modular lunar power grid.

Beyond engineering

  • Uncontrolled exponential replication; planetary-protection and galactic-scale consequences
  • Legal personhood of emulated minds