Mind uploading (software people)
Scanning a brain and running it as software, so a person continues to live, think and be copied inside a computer, at whatever clock rate the hardware allows.
In shortMind uploading (software people), from Permutation City (Greg Egan, 1994) and Diaspora (Greg Egan, 1997), is at technology readiness level 2 of 9 (technology concept formulated) at its weakest link. Held back by Whole-brain emulation, Molecular annotation of synapses at scale, Mechanistic theory of neural computation and In-vivo recording of a whole brain at single-neuron resolution. Science status: consistent with known physics; key effects unproven at scale. Estimated new funding to unlock: $26B–181B (a floor; some parts are priced only to early research).
Copies are scanned brains run at a fraction of real-time on leased processors, able to be paused, branched and run on arbitrary substrates.
Citizens of the polises are software minds whose exoselves manage memory and sensoria; fleshers who scan are run in distributed polis hardware.
Closest todayConnectome-constrained fly brain simulations; no mammalian brain has been scanned or emulated.
Dependency stack
- Running a specific person as software is exactly this capability
- Unknown sufficient level of detail; no accepted criterion for when an emulation is the same person
- Static connectomes lack synaptic weights, neuromodulatory state and glial contributions
- Validation problem; without the original brain's activity you cannot check the copy
plausibleTRL 2- Wiring without weights and molecular state does not specify a mind
- Unknown which molecular species are sufficient to infer functional synaptic weight
- Antibody or barcode multiplexing depth, and uniform labeling across centimetre-scale tissue
- Fixation chemistry that preserves both ultrastructure and labile post-translational state
plausibleTRL 2- Mechanistic theory of neural computationbottleneckTheory decides which molecular variables must be measured at all
- Unknown sufficient level of biological detail
plausibleTRL 2- Wiring diagrams constrain and test circuit models
✕3 blockers›
- Human proofreading of AI segmentation dominates cost; 2025 methods imply tens of billions of dollars for one mouse brain
- Imaging throughput and storage; a human brain at EM resolution is of order 100+ exabytes of raw data
- Sectioning or expanding whole large brains without tissue loss or distortion
TRL 3- Ultrastructure must survive preservation before it can be imaged
✕3 blockers›
- Ischemic damage starts within minutes of circulatory arrest, before perfusion can begin
- Aldehyde fixation may destroy molecular state (phosphorylation, receptor conformation) that could carry memory
- No assay proves preserved tissue still contains the information an emulation would need
TRL 4 - Automated segmentation and tracing of exabyte-scale image volumes
✕2 blockers›
- Grid power and interconnection queues
- Advanced-node chip and HBM memory supply
TRL 8
- Molecular readout is only useful registered to every traced synapseTRL 3
- Determines which biological detail must be simulated for cognition to appearplausibleTRL 2
- Activity from the source brain is the only way to validate the emulation
- Optical methods cannot penetrate a human skull or image below ~1 mm of tissue
- Channel count, heat dissipation and uplink bandwidth for ~86 billion neurons
- Displaced tissue volume and vascular damage scale with the number of inserted probes
plausibleTRL 2- Whole-brain coverage needs sensors orders of magnitude smaller than current shanks
✕3 blockers›
- No scheme to individually power and address millions of untethered sub-cellular devices
- Egress bandwidth; nanoparticles can stimulate but cannot yet report spikes off-board
- Clearance, aggregation and long-term toxicity of persistent intraparenchymal devices
plausibleTRL 3- Non-surgical delivery requires crossing from blood into brain parenchyma
✕3 blockers›
- Receptor targeting is species-specific; capsids binding human TfR1 often fail in macaque
- Pre-existing anti-AAV immunity excludes a large fraction of patients and blocks redosing
- Dose needed for brain-wide coverage drives liver toxicity and manufacturing cost
TRL 4- Designed capsid and shuttle proteins are the main route to receptor-specific transcytosis
✕1 blocker›
- Designing catalysis and conformational dynamics
TRL 6
- Devices resident in tissue for decades must not provoke encapsulation
✕3 blockers›
- Micromotion between rigid device and pulsating tissue drives chronic inflammation
- Thin-film encapsulation (polyimide, parylene, SiC) eventually admits water and fails
- Electrode charge-injection limits and corrosion under years of continuous stimulation
TRL 4
- Recording must remain stable for the duration of a life, not monthsTRL 4
- Electrode arrays are today's only route to single-neuron recording in humans
✕2 blockers›
- Tissue response degrades signal over years
- Channel count and wireless bandwidth
TRL 6- Channel count is limited by wireless data and power budget
✕3 blockers›
- Tissue heating caps implant power at a few hundred milliwatts, which bounds radio and compute
- Raw broadband neural data exceeds the link, forcing on-implant spike detection and compression
- Battery or wireless-power lifetime versus the decades a permanent interface implies
TRL 5- Implant power density sets what telemetry and on-board compute are affordable
✕2 blockers›
- Cycle life of lithium-metal anodes
- Thermal runaway safety
TRL 6
- An individual's wiring diagram is the irreducible inputTRL 3
- Running the model at biological speed requires brain-scale compute
✕3 blockers›
- Synaptic state alone needs petabytes of high-bandwidth memory, which dominates cost
- All-to-all spike traffic makes the problem interconnect-bound, not FLOP-bound
- Energy per synaptic event is ~1e6 times worse than biology, so a real-time human emulation implies large power draw
TRL 4- The same accelerator, power and interconnect supply chain is the base for brain-scale machinesTRL 8
- The individual's wiring must be measured at synaptic resolutionTRL 3
- An upload that thinks at human speed needs brain-scale compute per personTRL 4
- Determines what level of biological detail must be captured for the mind to survive the copyplausibleTRL 2
- Destructive scanning requires the brain to be preserved intact firstTRL 4
Who could unlock it
- Across several requirements:
- E11 Bio 3
- Allen Institute 3
- Philip Shiu 2
- Eon SystemsStartupRan a FlyWire-based whole fly brain emulation driving a MuJoCo body through multiple behaviors (2026); targeting a mouse emulation
- Philip ShiuResearcher, Eon SystemsAuthor of the whole Drosophila brain computational model (Nature 2024) and co-author of the State of Brain Emulation Report 2025
- Carboncopies FoundationProgramNon-profit coordinating WBE research, a Brain Emulation Challenge and an emulation ethics framework (2025)
- HHMI Janelia FlyEMAcademic labPublished the complete Drosophila central nervous system connectome (2025-2026), the data emulations depend on
- Seth GrantResearcher, University of EdinburghBuilt synaptome maps quantifying synapse protein composition brain-wide across the mouse lifespan, now extended to human tissue
- E11 BioProgramPRISM pairs protein barcodes with iterative immunostaining in expanded tissue to annotate connectomes molecularly (2025 preprint)
- Ed BoydenResearcher, MIT McGovern InstituteInventor of expansion microscopy, the base method for multiplexed nanoscale protein mapping
- Allen InstituteAcademic labCell-type atlases and MICrONS synapse-level datasets used to relate structure to synaptic function
- Philip ShiuResearcher, Eon SystemsBuilt the leaky integrate-and-fire whole fly brain model that predicts sensorimotor circuit responses (Nature 2024)
- Srinivas TuragaResearcher, HHMI Janelia Research CampusCo-led connectome-constrained networks that predict neural activity across the fly visual system (Nature 2024)
- Larry AbbottResearcher, Columbia UniversityTheoretical neuroscientist; co-director of the Zuckerman Institute's Center for Theoretical Neuroscience
- Allen InstituteAcademic labMICrONS functional connectomics and a 230,000-cell biophysical model of mouse visual cortex
- Alipasha VaziriResearcher, The Rockefeller UniversityLight beads microscopy recorded up to 1 million neurons across mouse dorsal cortex (Neuron 2024)
- Mikhail ShapiroResearcher, CaltechDevelops ultrasound and acoustic reporter genes for deep, noninvasive brain-activity readout
- Arbor Neuroscience (formerly Forest Neurotech)ProgramConvergent Research FRO founded 2023 by Caltech scientists to build whole-brain ultrasound sensing and modulation, backed by Eric and Wendy Schmidt
- Neuropixels consortium (HHMI Janelia, imec)ProgramDense silicon probes that record thousands of neurons per animal; the standard tool for large-scale electrophysiology
- E11 BioProgramPhilanthropic FRO whose PRISM protein-barcoding expansion microscopy (2025) aims for a 100x cheaper, proofreading-free mouse connectome
- Andrew PayneResearcher, E11 BioCo-founder and CEO of E11 Bio, leading the PRISM optical connectomics effort
- Sebastian SeungResearcher, Princeton UniversityCo-led FlyWire, the first complete adult fly brain connectome of 139,255 neurons (Nature 2024)
- Allen InstituteAcademic labLeads a NIH BRAIN CONNECTS center scaling EM pipelines toward a whole mouse connectome; key MICrONS contributor
- Anton ArkhipovResearcher, Allen Institute for Brain ScienceCo-led the November 2025 whole-mouse-cortex simulation of 9M biophysical neurons and 26B synapses on Fugaku, presented at SC25
- Tadashi YamazakiResearcher, University of Electro-Communications, TokyoCo-led the same work and built Neulite, the simulator that made biophysical neuron dynamics tractable at that scale
- Allen Institute for Brain ScienceAcademic labSupplies the Cell Types Database, Connectivity Atlas and Brain Modeling ToolKit that turn measured anatomy into runnable models
- RIKEN Center for Computational ScienceGovernment labOperates Fugaku (>400 petaflops), the machine on which the current largest biophysical cortex simulation ran, still far slower than biological real time
- Robert McIntyreResearcher, NectomeDeveloped aldehyde-stabilized cryopreservation (Cryobiology 2015) and won the Large Mammal Brain Preservation Prize in 2018
- NectomeStartupAnnounced in 2026 a field protocol for whole-body preservation at subsynaptic detail, after working on the post-mortem timing problem from 2018 to 2025
- Sparks Brain PreservationCompanyNon-profit (formerly Oregon Brain Preservation) offering aldehyde-based preservation; published whole-brain fixed-tissue cryopreservation in PLOS One (2026)
- Andrew McKenzieResearcher, Sparks Brain PreservationLead on Sparks' studies of immersion fixation and aldehyde-based cryopreservation of human brains (2024-2026)
Beyond engineering
- No agreed test for whether an upload is conscious or is the same person
- Copies raise unresolved questions of identity, inheritance and voting rights
- Running costs make existence contingent on paying for compute